Health News Review
  • Oct 30 2009

    TV station makes big deal of showing breast exams but ignore evidence

    It’s a TV sweeps ratings period, and it’s also breast cancer awareness month, so any boob could see this coming. The Washington Post makes a big deal of the fact that DC station WJLA is making an even bigger deal about: “…breaking TV’s unspoken taboo by showing two women fully exposed on its late-afternoon and [...]

    No Comments
  • Oct 30 2009

    Something doesn’t feel right about FDA – WebMD partnership

    In the circles I run in, there’s been a buzz about an announcement first made last December about a “partnership” between the FDA and WebMD. Yesterday the two entities announced an expansion of that partnership “to provide increased access to FDA’s consumer health information.” I can appreciate the FDA’s interest in reaching the public more [...]

    No Comments
  • Oct 21 2009

    Attempted clarification by Cancer Society

    Excerpt from Dr. Len Lichtenfeld’s blog posting, criticizing both the JAMA article and the NYT article this week that raised questions about screening. “This was an opinion piece, not original research. It reiterated arguments that have been made before, and are certainly valid. But they represent the thoughts of several respected scientists, but not all [...]

    1 Comment
  • Oct 21 2009

    What IS the American Cancer Society trying to say about screening?

    Gina Kolata had her article in the Times – subject of my blog earlier today (below). Later, the American Cancer Society issued this news release (Is it a retraction? Is it a correction? Is it ‘we wish we hadn’t said that to the NYT?’ Is it “Gina Kolata got it wrong?’ What is it?).

    1 Comment
  • Oct 20 2009

    CBS proclaims miraculous results from lifesaving drug – but provides no evidence

    CBS News last night proclaimed the drug peramavir as a “lifesaving drug” for serious cases of H1N1 infection. Lines from the story: • “Experts caution its too early to see Peramivir as a miracle drug, but there’s no doubting the drugs connection to some miraculous results.” • “Human clinical trials in the U.S. and Japan [...]

    5 Comments
  • Oct 19 2009

    60 Minutes dusts off its #1 cancer story – for the third time

    CBS 60 Minutes once again devoted a big chunk of prime time last night to an unproven idea – which is fine, if you’re going to devote your show to such explorations of basic science all the time. But they don’t. And it shows. The subject was the pie-plates-and-radiowaves cancer experiment of inventor John Kanzius [...]

    No Comments
  • Oct 19 2009

    Troubling beliefs by health care journalists

    A writer posted a query on the Association of Health Care Journalists (AHCJ) listserv last week asking for ideas about state-of-the-art but underused treatments. Many of the responses were troubling. Some AHCJ members wrote in suggesting: • MRI is far superior to mammograms for detecting breast cancer (leading another member to write in asking where [...]

    No Comments
  • Oct 15 2009

    Raising chickens and grading health care news

    Maggie Koerth-Baker’s interview with me about HealthNewsReview.org- and how she connects it with her grandfather raising semi-feral chickens. !!!

    No Comments
  • Oct 8 2009

    NYDN story on Mediterranean diet & depression was, well, depressing

    HealthNewsReview.org review summary: A 183-word story just can’t do much. And this story didn’t. The NY paper clearly picked up the story from the BBC and passed along erroneous information about basic information such as where the study was published. But at the heart of the story was the improper and inaccurate use of causal [...]

    No Comments
  • Oct 8 2009

    Science Based Medicine blog calls CBS vaccine story “credulous, noncritical, misinformation”

    Dr. David Gorski writes: The quantity of misinformation in that single six minute video is far beyond the scope of this article. .. I leave the dissection of this pièce de résistance of disingenuousness and misinformation as an exercise for readers (of his blog).

    No Comments