Health News Review
  • Jan 23 2014

    A patient advocate’s powerful piece on Lisa Bonchek Adams and the Kellers’ criticism – the DCIS Sea of Uncertainty

    I’ve been slow to comment on the firestorm of criticism that arose when Emma Keller of The Guardian questioned the Twitter messages by Lisa Bonchek Adams, a young woman with stage IV breast cancer. I haven’t felt the need to comment since so many people have done such a thorough job of writing about this [...]

    5 Comments
  • Dec 20 2013

    Did people learn from Angelina Jolie breast cancer news coverage?

    No, according to a study published in the journal Genetics in Medicine this week. And the researchers had several direct messages for journalists, such as: Celebrities can successfully raise awareness about a health issue, but it is a greater challenge for health journalists to ensure accurate understanding. As our understanding of the genetic contribution to [...]

    3 Comments
  • Dec 13 2013

    Doing an autopsy on a feel-good local TV health news story…and the harms therein

    On the Skeptic Ink website, William London, EdD, MPH, a public health professor at California State University, Los Angeles, writes: “On July 12, 2013, I came upon a video recording and transcript of a typical feel-good local news feature: Local doctor battles cancer through natural healing. It appeared on KGET, the NBC affiliate station in [...]

    No Comments
  • Dec 10 2013

    The potential harms of screening – seen this time in lung cancer screening

    It is still a difficult concept for many people to grasp:  how can there be harms from screening for cancer? Maybe the study published this week in JAMA Internal Medicine, “Overdiagnosis in Low-Dose Computed Tomography Screening for Lung Cancer,” will make some of the potential harms a little more clear. The analysis shows that nearly [...]

    2 Comments
  • Oct 17 2013

    Canadian journalist: every cancer cure claim needs scrutiny

    Carly Weeks of The Globe and Mail, based in Toronto, writes, “Why every claim of an exciting new cancer cure needs close examination.” She begins: “The Internet loves a good conspiracy. Have you heard the one about scientists finding a cure for cancer, but it being blocked from the public because Big Pharma can’t make [...]

    2 Comments
  • Oct 15 2013

    News coverage that doesn’t learn from the past is condemned to repeat it

    It was more than 100 years ago when George Santayana wrote, “Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.” It was 1985 – 28 years ago – and Dr. Steven Rosenberg of the National Cancer Institute was a media darling with stories about his research on interleukin-2 for cancer.  Magazine covers, newspaper [...]

    5 Comments
  • Oct 15 2013

    Shuffle off to Buffalo for another questionable prostate screening promotion

    By now, any health care consumer with a pulse knows about the tradeoffs involved in prostate cancer screening.  It must have reached most corners of the US that mass prostate cancer screening is not recommended by: the US Preventive Services Task Force the American College of Physicians: “Doctors should inform men aged 50 to 69 [...]

    2 Comments
  • Oct 10 2013

    Awash in pink

    This is what breast cancer awareness looks like in many corners of our country this month. Pink Tow Trucks Take Breast Cancer Awareness On The Road Pink fire truck surprises cancer patients Paint Your Pinky Pink for Breast Cancer Awareness Month! Lighting Aerial Lift Bridge pink inspires breast cancer patients Even the beer is pink [...]

    4 Comments
  • Oct 9 2013

    Beware the polyp police

    Alan Cassels of British Columbia writes, “The polyp police are coming.” He explores the introduction of a new Provincial Colon Screening Program in British Columbia. And he raises many questions in a very thoughtful analysis: “Does a polyp automatically mean a death sentence? Not at all—only about 2.5 polyps in a thousand will progress to [...]

    4 Comments
  • Oct 8 2013

    When patients become pitchwomen: The duty of the medical journalist

    Another hospital claims a “first,” and another local newspaper bites on the bait, writing a story that is devoid of evidence but filled with one woman’s “success story.”  That’s just part of what bugged Theresa O’Brien when she read the story in her local paper.  Ms. O’Brien is a freelance technology and marketing analyst. She [...]

    1 Comment