We had two this week:
And here are some examples from the archives:
Just as you can’t judge a book by its cover, you can’t judge a story by its star score or grade. Please read our commentary. We give reasons why we voted satisfactory or unsatisfactory on each of 10 criteria. And there are times – as seen above – where stories address most or all of our criteria and still are lacking in key context, caveats or framing.