Whose Vox? Science/health story via news release

Posted By

Tags

Vox.com has established a clear pattern of solid science/health journalism.  In 2015, our team applied our systematic criteria to 6 Vox stories.  Four received 5-star scores, the other two received 4-star scores – one of the best performances we’ve tracked, albeit on a very small sample.  In addition, our blog’s Five Star Friday feature noted Vox efforts twice.

But we all have bad days, and one for Vox was yesterday – Sunday, January 3.

Vox published one of the most clear and total reprints of a health care news release that we’ve seen by a major news organization in quite some time.

Vox story via news releaseUnder a “Science & Health” banner, Vox published the headline, “Giving birth can be as hard on your body as running a marathon.” That headline is one of the few things not copied directly from a University of Michigan news release from December 1, 2015.

From the news release:

“If an athlete sustained a similar injury in the field, she’d be in an MRI machine in an instant,” said Janis Miller, associate professor at the U-M School of Nursing. “We have this thing where we tell women, ‘Well, you’re six weeks postpartum and now we don’t need to see you—you’ll be fine.’ But not all women feel fine after six weeks nor are ready to go back to work, and they aren’t crazy.”

In the Vox story:

“If an athlete sustained a similar injury in the field, she’d be in an MRI machine in an instant,” said lead researcher Janis Miller, an associate professor at the University of Michigan School of Nursing. “We have this thing where we tell women, ‘Well, you’re six weeks postpartum, and now we don’t need to see you — you’ll be fine.’ But not all women feel fine after six weeks nor are ready to go back to work, and they aren’t crazy.”

From the news release:

She recalls one patient who made her particularly sad.

“I walked into my office, and before she even said ‘Hi,’ the woman told me, ‘I know it’s all my fault because I didn’t do enough Kegel exercises,'” Miller said.

In the Vox story:

She recalled a heartbreaking incident in her own practice: “I walked into my office, and before she even said hi, the woman told me, ‘I know it’s all my fault because I didn’t do enough Kegel exercises,'” Miller said.

There was no independent expert voice in the Vox story.

When the story offers hyperlinks to the “study,” it actually links only to the university news release, not to the study.  When it hyperlinks to what a researcher “said,” it actually links only to the university news release with a printed quote attributed to that researcher.  “Said” implies that something was said in an interview conducted by the journalist.  To be accurate, the quote should have been attributed to the university news release.

Look, we know what it’s like to have to work on a holiday weekend – which is when this was published.  But it’s not like somebody couldn’t have found time to do an interview and to get an independent perspective in the month between the time the news release was published and the story was published.

You might also like

Comments

We Welcome Comments. But please note: We will delete comments left by anyone who doesn’t leave an actual first and last name and an actual email address.

We will delete comments that include personal attacks, unfounded allegations, unverified facts, product pitches, or profanity. We will also end any thread of repetitive comments. Comments should primarily discuss the quality (or lack thereof) in journalism or other media messages about health and medicine. This is not intended to be a forum for definitive discussions about medicine or science. Nor is it a forum to share your personal story about a disease or treatment -- your comment must relate to media messages about health care. If your comment doesn't adhere to these policies, we won't post it. Questions? Please see more on our comments policy.

Comments are closed.