• Story Reviews
  • News Release Reviews
  • Blog
  • Podcasts
  • About Us
  • Toolkit for journalists and consumers
  • Contact
  • Newsletter Signup
HealthNewsReview.org HealthNewsReview.org HealthNewsReview.org
  • 2616 Story Reviews
  • 606 News Release Reviews
  • 2946 Blog Posts
  • Home
  • Story Reviews
  • News Release Reviews
  • Blog
  • Podcasts
  • About Us
    • Editorial Team
    • What We Review and How
    • Review Criteria
    • How Is the Star Score Determined?
    • Our Comments Policy
    • Accolades for HealthNewsReview.org
    • Talks, Workshops & Presentations
  • Toolkit
    • Tips for Analyzing Studies & Health Care Claims
    • Just for Journalists: Writing Tips
    • Stories of Patient Harm from Misleading Media
    • Pre-publication News Release Review
    • Health News Watchdog podcasts
    • News Sites & Blogs We Like
    • List of Industry-Independent Experts
    • Links to Other Resources
  • Contact

Search Results for "overdiagnosis cancer"

October 17, 2018 | News Release Review

News release touts universal blood test for cancer, but what about overdiagnosis?

It’s important to keep in mind that all cancer screening tests carry risks.

2 Star
University of Bradford

'Universal' blood test for earlier diagnosis of cancer moves closer to market

10/1/2015

Podcast: Pathologic profiling – Dr. Otis Brawley on cancer overdiagnosis

Despite many advances in studying cancer, we still use a definition of cancer from the 1850s. That’s what Dr. Otis Brawley, chief medical officer of the American Cancer Society, told the recent Preventing Overdiagnosis 2015 conference at the National Institutes of Health.

3 7/29/2013

Cautions on cancer screening, overdiagnosis and overtreatment

Several noteworthy articles in journals today. In JAMA, a breast cancer specialist, a prostate cancer specialist, and an esophogeal cancer specialist co-authored a Viewpoint article, “Overdiagnosis and Overtreatment in Cancer: An Opportunity for Improvement.” Excerpt: “In March 2012, the National Cancer Institute convened a meeting to evaluate the problem of “overdiagnosis,” which occurs when tumors […]

4 7/26/2010

New data raising concerns over overdiagnosis & overtreatment of prostate cancer

What’s known about the characteristics of men being treated aggressively for prostate cancer? Up to now, not much. A study published in the Archives of Internal Medicine describes “the first large-scale US population-based study to document the risk profiles and treatment patterns among men with PSA levels of 4.0 ng/mL or lower who were diagnosed […]

2 4/23/2010

Overdiagnosis in cancer & role of shared decision-making

Gil Welch and Bill Black of Dartmouth address cancer overdiagnosis in a new review article in the Journal of the National Cancer Institute. Excerpt from the abstract: “We estimated the magnitude of overdiagnosis from randomized trials: about 25% of mammographically detected breast cancers, 50% of chest x-ray and/or sputum-detected lung cancers, and 60% of prostate-specific […]

11/7/2019

Theranos redux? Not really. But claim of a ‘simple’ test for breast cancer warrants scrutiny

Once again the lure of a “simple” test has made headlines. This time the catalyst was a news release issued by the UK’s National Cancer Research Institute. Its title: “Simple blood test for early detection of breast cancer.” In fact, no such test exists. As the body of the PR news release acknowledged, it’s an […]

9/10/2018

How overdiagnosis and other harms can undermine the benefits of screening: A new primer in our toolkit

  September marks National Prostate Health Month, when hospitals and urology practices push free prostate cancer screening. It’s also when we at HealthNewsReview.org publish our annual analysis of why these promotions — and their “screening saves lives” message — are bad for men. To help readers understand the issue more clearly, we’ve published an expanded toolkit […]

9/10/2018

Screening: How overdiagnosis and other harms can undermine the benefits

“Screening saves lives.” We’ve all seen that seductive message. The idea behind screening — catching disease early when it’s easiest to treat — sounds good, but it can be misleading. Screening means testing people who don’t have signs or symptoms of the disease. It might save some people from a fate such as dying of […]

June 14, 2018 | Story Review

Here’s one detail that should be included in almost all stories about cancer screening studies

This is an oversight we see often in news stories reporting on research about new cancer screening tests.

3 Star
Newsweek

NEW PROSTATE CANCER DNA SPIT TEST DEVELOPED BY SCIENTISTS

6/6/2018

Questions about a ‘simple blood test’ to screen for cancer prompt revealing answer: It’s complicated

We often tell our readers to run for the hills whenever they see a news story touting a “simple blood test.” You won’t find a better example of why you need to be wary than an exchange between a reporter and a researcher at a news conference at the American Society of Clinical Oncology’s annual […]

1
5/11/2018

A win for readers: coverage of new prostate cancer screening guidelines focuses on shared decision making

When the United States Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF) issued a statement recommending against prostate cancer screening in 2012, its guidance was met with often vituperative attacks from professional organizations and advocacy groups. The muted response to new recommendations released this past Tuesday supporting personalized decision making for men 55 to 69 must have come as […]

3
5/3/2018

Despite screaming headlines, England’s breast cancer screening computer glitch didn’t kill anyone

A bureaucratic snafu in England has generated international headlines bemoaning the deaths of hundreds of women. Some coverage, such as this CNN story picked up by KSAT in San Antonio, brought visions of a mass casualty event on the scale of a terrorist attack or airline crash: Dozens of other news outlets chimed in with similarly […]

scrutiny-dependent cancers
1/8/2018

Could finding more cancer lead us to understand risk factors less?

An opinion piece in last week’s Annals of Internal Medicine argues that just how aggressively we screen for some cancers can actually distort our understanding of the risk factors for a particular cancer, as well as how common we perceive it to be. The authors describe ‘scrutiny-dependent’ cancers  — those subtypes of cancers often picked […]

3
9/26/2017

A prostate ‘Pep Talk’ is the wrong way to get men thinking about cancer screening

With September’s Prostate Cancer Awareness Month in full swing, an industry-affiliated partnership has turned to high-profile former NFL coaches to deliver its prostate cancer screening message. It’s a clever choice: professional coaches are good at getting men to do all kinds of things they might not otherwise want to do, whether it’s extra wind sprints […]

August 21, 2017 | Story Review

NBC News doesn’t back away from shortcomings of new blood test for early cancer detection

It outlines some of the potential risks as well as the benefits of the proposed test, and adequately explains that it is not yet ready for prime time.

5 Star
NBCNews.com

Blood Test Finds Cancer Before Symptoms Start

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • …
  • 9
  • Next »

Toolkit

Tips & Resources for Analyzing Health Care Claims

Surrogate markers may not tell the whole story

Screening: How overdiagnosis and other harms can undermine the benefits

A place to tell stories of patient harm from misleading media

View More

Toolkit

Institutional Home

University of Minnesota - School of Public Health
  • Home
  • Story Reviews
  • News Release Reviews
  • Blog
  • About Us
  • Toolkit
  • Contact

Copyright © 2022 HealthNewsReview.org