Podcast: Trying to make breast cancer decisions while conflicting news stories swirl about

In another episode in our ad hoc series of podcasts on how patients can be harmed by flawed news stories, we introduce another breast cancer patient story.

Melissa Phipps, 44, is a journalist, a mother of two sons, and, for the last year, a breast cancer patient. In the photos at right you see her at various stages, including losing her hair after chemotherapy.

Her story is compelling because it helps you reflect on what it’s like to hear widespread news stories about people similar to you in age and in condition, but who promote treatment choices very different than what was recommended for you – all while in the midst of trying to make vital treatment choices yourself. And because some of the people in question are celebrities, their stories get an inordinate amount of attention. This may even lead friends and colleagues to wonder and ask you why you didn’t do what those celebrities did.

Phipps wrote to me, “I started to worry. Had I opted for a lesser treatment on the advice of my doctors? Did I make a mistake? I asked my oncologist, who said the same thing the surgeon had said. These days, doctors try to preserve the breast tissue. I asked a nurse practitioner, a gynecologist, each time I received the same answer. But in the media, it seems that the double mastectomy is the only sensible option.” Hear more in our podcast interview with her, which includes her advice to journalists about how to do a better job reporting on breast cancer.

Links to related material:

Stories submitted to me by Melissa Phipps that may have hurt more than helped as she was trying to make treatment decisions:

• She writes: “I am particularly frustrated by The New York Times‘ coverage, which confuses the issue of increased breast cancer risk with the BRCA gene with surgery to remove cancer. And in either case, the advice itself is confusing. This is a recent article.” No Regrets After Double Mastectomy, but Questions Remain – New York Times Well blog
• An example of “terrible reporting,” in Phipps’ view – “Sandra Lee has breast cancer, will undergo double mastectomy” – Eonline.com

The ABC Good Morning America clip used in the podcast was from May 12, 2015.

Other stories got mixed reactions from Phipps:

• An Opinion piece by Peggy Orenstein in the Times that basically “gets it right” in her view:
• A companion piece to a People magazine article about actress Rita Wilson. Phipps wrote: “The doctor has a reasonable approach, but seems to indicate that if it is invasive, a bilateral mastectomy makes perfect sense.”
• Another People piece with good details, in her view, on Wilson’s story.
• Phipps wrote: “Elizabeth Wurtzel is another celebrity (author) I read about. In her case, the BRCA gene was present, so her double mastectomy made sense.”
• “This is an article that I liked for the diversity of treatment stories,” Phipps wrote, “but the reporting is not deep (and in some cases specifics are not covered).”

By the way, Phipps has a new book that’s just been published, “The Retirement Rescue Plan.” It’s not directly related to breast cancer, but we told you that she’s a journalist, and this is evidence of her work.

In case you missed it, we recently produced a related Podcast with AnneMarie Ciccarella, ChemoBrainFog blogger and breast cancer patient, who has similar complaints about celebrity breast cancer treatment news. The two podcast stories combined represent a wealth of smart perspectives from women who’ve been there.

Thanks to The National Institute for Health Care Management Foundation for providing us with a grant to produce these podcasts.

Credit: podcast editor Cristeta Boarini

Musical bridge used in this episode: “Mad World” by Gary Jules

Please note: if you have listened to any of our podcasts and like what you’ve heard, we’d appreciate it if you’d leave a Review and a Rating on the iTunes webpage where our podcasts can be found: https://itun.es/i6S86Qw. (You need to click on the “View in iTunes” button on the left of that page, then find the Ratings and Reviews tab.)

You can now subscribe to our podcasts on that iTunes page or via this RSS feed: http://feeds.soundcloud.com/users/soundcloud:users:167780656/sounds.rss

All episodes of our podcasts are archived on this page on HealthNewsReview.org.